Peach & Lily Review: What I Loved, What I’d Skip

Peach & Lily is one of those skincare brands I really wanted to love across the board. The brand philosophy, ingredient focus, and overall aesthetic are all very much my vibe. That said, my experience was a mix of clear wins, a few surprises, and some products that just didn’t work for my skin.

Below is an honest breakdown of the Peach & Lily products I’ve tried, what worked for me, and what I wouldn’t repurchase.

Peach and Lily Review

Power Calm Hydrating Gel Cleanser

I was pleasantly surprised by this cleanser. After using it, my face felt clean but not stripped, and it didn’t leave behind any residue, which is a big win for me. It’s gentle, effective, and easy to use daily. I currently have a full-size in my bathroom and a travel size that lives in my gym bag, which tells you how often I reach for it.

Would I repurchase? Yes. This is a solid, reliable cleanser that works well for my sensitive skin.

Wild Dew Treatment Essence

This is one of my favorites from the brand and something I would 100% repurchase. Key ingredients include lotus extract, niacinamide, hyaluronic acid, and allantoin. I usually try to limit niacinamide because of my sensitive skin, but as long as I don’t layer this with other niacinamide-heavy products, my skin tolerates it just fine.

I love how lightweight it is. It provides a thin layer of hydration that feels especially nice in the summer. In the winter, I personally need to layer more hydration on top. Overall, it helps hydrate and soothe the skin while also giving a subtle brightening effect.

Would I repurchase? Yes, absolutely. This is a standout for me.

Glass Skin Veil Mist

I can’t believe I’m saying this, but the mister on this product is too fine. I have to use a lot of sprays to even feel like I’ve applied anything to my skin. It’s extremely lightweight and won’t make your skin feel greasy at all.

Key ingredients include cucumber water, lotus extract, peach extract, and reishi mushroom, and it’s meant to replenish, calm, and soothe the skin. While it feels nice, I’m not totally convinced it’s doing much.

Would I repurchase? Probably not.

Matcha Pudding Antioxidant Cream

This is one of Peach & Lily’s most popular products, so I was genuinely surprised that my skin didn’t like it. I actually really enjoyed the weight of this cream. It wasn’t too heavy or greasy and felt like it would be a great everyday moisturizer.

Unfortunately, it made my face red and irritated, with a noticeable burning sensation. It does contain niacinamide, but I’m not entirely sure if that’s what caused the reaction. Either way, it was clear my skin wasn’t happy.

Would I repurchase? No. As much as I wanted this one to work, it just didn’t agree with my skin.

Rescue Party Barrier Comfort Cream

This is a more occlusive moisturizer. It isn’t heavy, but you can definitely feel a slight film on the skin, likely from the synthetic beeswax. Because of that, this is something I would only use at night. That being said, there are other barrier-repairing moisturizers that I personally enjoy more.

Would I repurchase? No.

Collagen Peptide Lip Balm

There are so many peptide and treatment-style lip balms on the market right now, at pretty much every price point, that the formula really has to be perfect for me to repurchase.

With this one, a little definitely goes a long way; be careful not to squeeze out too much. There is an artificial scent if you smell the tube, but I don’t notice it once it’s on the lips. Unfortunately, the texture is a bit thicker and stickier than I prefer.

Would I repurchase? No. I’ll keep buying this one instead.

Glass Skin Face Polisher️

This product reminds me a lot of Tatcha’s The Rice Polish, but at a much lower price point. Normally, I don’t love this type of exfoliant because they can feel like more trouble than they’re worth. I usually prefer an exfoliating face wash.

That said, I loved this. It left my skin feeling incredibly soft, smooth, and polished without irritation.

Would I repurchase? Yes. This is one I would happily buy again.

Glass Skin Refining Serum

This is another very popular product from Peach & Lily. Unfortunately, for me, this is essentially a niacinamide serum. That can be great if your skin tolerates niacinamide well, but my sensitive skin just can’t handle it at this concentration.

I experienced irritation when testing this serum, so this isn’t something I can continue using. I’ll be sticking with the Wild Dew Treatment Essence instead, which gives me just the right amount of niacinamide without upsetting my skin.

Would I repurchase? No.

Ginger Melt Oil Cleanser

I had heard this was one of the best oil cleansers for a double cleanse, so I had to pick it up to try. I don’t wear heavy or hard-to-remove makeup day to day, but for the sake of this review, I used it to remove regular mascara, eyeliner, and eyeshadow.

Even though I’m not a heavy makeup wearer, it removed all of my makeup easily and, most importantly, didn’t irritate my eyes, which is a major win for me. While it is more expensive than my Haruharu Wonder Oil Cleanser, I did really enjoy using it.

Would I repurchase? Yes.

Copper Peptide Pro Firming Serum ️

I love a copper peptide serum, so when I saw Peach & Lily had one, I had to try it. Copper peptide products tend to be more expensive in general, but they’re one of my favorite ingredient categories because they do so much for the skin.

One thing I really appreciate about this serum is the packaging. It comes with a pump, which makes dispensing and applying the product so much easier. A lot of copper peptide serums I’ve tried use droppers, and this just feels more practical and less messy.

The formula itself feels elegant and easy to layer, and it fits well into a routine focused on long-term skin health rather than instant results.

Would I repurchase? Yes. This is a formula I would happily buy again.

Final Thoughts

Overall, my experience with Peach & Lily was a mix of clear standouts and a few products that just weren’t right for my skin. The brand really shines when it comes to gentle hydration, thoughtful formulations, and products that support long-term skin health rather than quick fixes. While not everything worked for my sensitive skin, several items earned a firm yes and a place in my routine.

If you’re curious about Peach & Lily, I think it’s a brand worth exploring, especially if you value elegant textures and skin-barrier-focused formulas. As always, skincare is personal, and what didn’t work for me may be a favorite for someone else. Hopefully, this review helps you decide which products are worth trying.

Shop Peach & Lily at Ulta